The Charming Paladin 1
Bravery can be tough to come by, and Marco has asked you for a Good-Quality Charm to bolster his backbone. It's a snap for a Fledgling Alchemist!
Goal
Charm × 1Reward
Apple Appliqué × 1Chain
Leads to 
The Charming Paladin 2
Dialogue
MarcoThis castle gives me the creeps, especially at night.
I'm always afraid these suits of armor will get me.
Ah, what a coward I am! If only I had something
to make me feel braver...
like a protective charm or something.
A Good-Quality Charm!
I wonder, could you bring me one? I know it would
really help!
I've heard even Fledgling Alchemists can make them
quite easily.
In return, I'll give you an Apple Appliqué and 800 of
my hard-earned Dosh!
[Choice: Accept / Decline]
MarcoOh, thank you!
I know I'll feel so much more secure with a protective
charm to keep me safe!
MarcoOh, you don't think the Apple Appliqué is worth
the trade?
I assure you it's worthwhile! My sister made it. She
says it wards off evil! Or was it weevils?
Anyway...I don't think it's going to help me much if
those suits of armor decide to attack!
MarcoDid you bring me what I wanted? Do you have a
Good-Quality Charm for me?
[Choice: Hand over / Keep for now]
MarcoWow, thank you so much! Here's your reward!
MarcoOh, how cruel! Please reconsider! I swear I saw one
of those suits of armor twitch!
MarcoYou are not afraid. You are not afraid. You are a
strong, confident Paladin.
The suits of armor are just suits of armor. They are
not going to eat you.
I repeat...they are not going to eat you. Probably.